Savings

GIC vs HISA vs Savings Account: Where to Put Your Cash

You have cash to save. Here's how to choose the right account for your situation.

By Ahmad Jamal · Published November 22, 2025 · 6 min read

Cash sitting in a chequing account earning next to nothing is a quiet kind of waste. The real question isn't whether to move it, it's where: a GIC, a high-interest savings account (HISA), or a plain savings account. Here's how to tell which one actually fits your situation.

Quick Answer

A HISA is the better default for most people; a GIC only makes sense once you know exactly when you'll need the money. HISAs keep cash fully accessible at a typical 2.5-3.5% variable rate, the right home for an emergency fund. GICs lock money for a fixed term (30 days to 5 years) at a higher guaranteed rate, typically 3-4%, but charge a penalty for early withdrawal. Regular savings, at 0.5-2%, is mainly for day-to-day float.

Quick Comparison

When you don't want cash sitting in the market, you're really choosing between three tools. Here's how they compare at a glance.

FeatureGICHISARegular Savings
Typical Rate3-4%2.5-3.5%0.5-2%
Access
Rate GuaranteedYes (term)No (variable)No
Best ForFixed goalsEmergency fundDaily banking

Rates shown are typical ranges, not live quotes, and move with the Bank of Canada's policy rate. Check current rates before you open anything.

You're in good company

Don't take our word for it. See what people are saying about us on Trustpilot.

Maxime
Ryan Plester
Jodi Harbarenko
Byra Dineshkumar
Stevie Baker

Trusted by 8,000+ budgeters

4.6/5 on Trustpilot

GICs (Guaranteed Investment Certificates)

A GIC locks your money away for a fixed term, anywhere from 30 days to 5 years, in exchange for a guaranteed rate. The longer the term, typically the higher the rate.

GIC Pros

  • The highest guaranteed rates of the three
  • Your rate is locked in. It won't drop even if the market does
  • CDIC insured up to $100,000
  • Forces you to save, since you can't easily spend it

GIC Cons

Your money is locked for the term, so pulling it out early usually means a penalty or lost interest. If rates rise while you're locked in, you miss out. And because it isn't accessible, a GIC is the wrong home for an emergency fund.

HISAs (High-Interest Savings Accounts)

A HISA pays a better rate than a regular savings account while keeping your money fully accessible. The rate is variable, so it moves with the market instead of staying fixed.

Best HISA Use Case: Emergency Fund

If you need instant access to money in a crunch, a HISA gives you a decent return while keeping the funds available the moment you need them.

My Recommendation by Goal

Recommendation by Goal

  • Emergency fund: a HISA. You need access, but it should still earn something while it sits there.
  • Known expense, 6+ months out: a GIC. Lock in the rate for that specific date.
  • Down payment, saving over time: a mix. HISA for what you're still contributing, a GIC ladder for what you've already saved.
  • Daily float or bill money: regular savings or chequing. Convenience matters more than rate here.

TFSA vs Non-Registered: Where to Hold Cash

Both GICs and HISAs can sit inside or outside a TFSA. Interest earned on either is taxable, so holding them in a TFSA makes sense if you have the room. Check your TFSA contribution room before assuming you have space. If your TFSA is already invested for growth, keeping a non-registered HISA for your emergency fund works fine too.

The Bottom Line

There's no single "best" account here, only the right tool for the job. A HISA is where your emergency fund lives, ready the moment you need it. Size yours with our emergency fund calculator. A GIC is for money with a deadline, like a down payment or tuition you can already see coming. Regular savings is just for the float that covers daily banking, nothing more. None of this needs to be complicated: match the account to the timeline, and the rest takes care of itself.

Ready to build your emergency fund?

Waypoint Budget helps you track savings goals and watch your progress over time, whichever account you keep the cash in.

Start Saving Free

No credit card required.

Disclaimer

This article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, investment, or legal advice. Contribution limits, tax rates, benefit amounts, and government program rules are approximate and change over time. Always verify current figures directly with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) and consult a qualified financial advisor, accountant, or tax professional before making decisions about your money. Waypoint Budget does not provide professional financial advice, and using our content does not create an advisory relationship.